The Loneliness of Flowers (1976) by Mihai Constantinescu - drama film online on CINEPUB

by Victor Morozov

Singurătatea florilor (The Loneliness of Flowers; Mihai Constantinescu, 1976) is a kind of Collateral avant la lettre: in place of Jamie Foxx and Tom Cruise we have our very own Toma Caragiu and Radu Beligan, the car is a docile Dacia 1300 and, thank the Lord, right to the end there is never any question of anybody dying. Although the sidewalk philosophy prattled without mercy by the poor performers is enough to kindle the killer instinct in any viewer…

In 1976, director Mihai Constantinescu (not to be confused with the singer of the same name) enjoyed a good standing in the profession. In Cinema magazine, the film critic Eva Sîrbu had concluded her litany of metaphors embroidered around Constantinescu’s previous title, from 1975, with a prophecy: “Tată de duminică [Sunday Father] is the whisper of a director who seems to have something to say. Something to say out loud. Let us wait. Nothing prevents us from waiting. Nothing gives us the right to doubt that this something will be said in the next film. Let us wait.” The wait was a short one. A year later, as if to satisfy “in more than full measure” the hope placed in him, the filmmaker returned with two titles: Singurătatea florilor and Premiera (The Premiere). The fact is not merely anecdotal: taken together, the three films reveal a little creative factory, with collaborators who move fluidly from one project to the next (Beligan, representatively, passes through all three in his turtleneck, a steadfast icon, as does Dumitru Costache-Fony, the director of photography), with kindred themes (lonely masculinity, tormented marriage), and so on. Seen today, they come across as gestures made in haste, bringing together a remote-controlled parable and some run-of-the-mill job opportunities for the actors, who were assured of meeting their audience again at the end of an effort involving minimal risk.

The Loneliness of Flowers (1976) by Mihai Constantinescu - drama film online on CINEPUB

It is not at all clear, however, what that “something” Constantinescu was destined to say might be. Singurătatea florilor has much in common with Tată de duminică, probably the best-known title of this now-forgotten filmmaker (he died in July 2026, at the age of 93, having spent the second half of his career in television). Both were written by Octav Pancu-Iași, a children’s author who died suddenly in 1975, before the films had actually reached the screen. They are, as their titles suggest, films of Sundays, of vacations, of rest—they unfold in an eternal present, in the sense of a frozen, sapless instant. Here, socialist blossoming has given way to an existential wilting. These are the films of an “after,” without it being very clear what existed “before.” Their hour is the afternoon. This anemia gets dressed up in all sorts of ways: “Mihai Constantinescu responded with care,” the same Eva Sîrbu tells us. “With care and with delicacy. He treated this delicate film with the attentiveness and dexterity of rose pickers.” Călin Căliman, a noted historian, wrote for his part in his well-known work: “An idea by Teodor Mazilu and a screenplay by Octav Pancu-Iași formed the basis of the film—sensitive and delicate—Singurătatea florilor.” So much delicacy, however, looks rather like the sign of a calcium deficiency: the films drag, at once limp and full of bombast.

Singurătatea florilor tries to be sprightly and springlike but, in the form in which it reaches us, its image is yellowish, sickly, that of an Indian summer. Toma Caragiu, duly suited at the wheel of his taxi, seems forever on the point of breaking into a sweat—it is warmer than one would suppose. The streets are empty, and the film’s interest lies, beyond the feeble plot, in this aimless drive through the neighborhoods of Bucharest: what comes into being is a proto-Angela merge mai departe (Angela Goes On; Lucian Bratu, 1981), minus the social coloring and minus the genial assurance of that film’s mise-en-scène. We pass through Colentina and through Titan, discovering a great socialist city with new districts in the thick of construction, as in a triumphalist tourist-office brochure, before which the camera cannot conceal its fascination. But that is not enough: the documentary gaze is never allowed to roam free, we keep coming back to the car’s interior and to the syrupy confections of Pancu-Iași the lyricist: “It must be a good 15 to 20 kilometers” to a certain address in Titan, says the cabbie from just past the Arch of Triumph. “To the Moon it’s a little further…!” replies his dandy of a client, gazing wistfully out the window. “Yes, but not by taxi!”

Time dilates around these individuals, the screenplay sketching a simple class conflict: the starchy intellectual, bowed under grave dilemmas, happens to climb into the passenger seat of a man of the people, who will overwhelm him (and us along with him) with counsel, witticisms, clever pensées, and an unflagging perkiness over the course of one fateful day. The former, a doctor by profession, revisits people dear to him: all of them, following the same pattern, send him packing from their lives—his ex-wife, his former comrade from the workplace (George Constantin, caught in a rugby sequence in which he lays into his cadets), his older brother (Colea Răutu, impeccable as a worker soured by the class privilege of the protagonist, for whom he sacrificed himself in his youth).

Caragiu plays a no-nonsense sort of fellow here: he hugs puppies in the street, drinks country wine, and helps out his younger confrere (Gheorghe Visu as a whippersnapper touched by Beatles fever, who has an exam at night school) after first blowing into the breathalyzer tube to make sure he is fit to drive. He is, in other words, a model citizen: in case we were not convinced, we discover him in his own home, surrounded by six children and a grandson, launching into a veiled plea for the Decree (the 1966 ban on abortion): “Better one than none… the ones with none at all, let them do the complaining… poor wretches, the devil knows how they get by…” It is clear who the bad guy is in this story: the doctor is divorced, and his daughter—his only one—pokes fun at him whenever he dares to show his face at home. But that is hardly surprising: at the outset, we see her (Micaela Caracaș) enunciating with great emphasis, “E mișto!” (“It’s cool!”), and we know, this being a dime-a-dozen communist film, that this mișto is no mere word—it is a statement about the times. “It’s what?” asks a puzzled Beligan from behind his tinted glasses. “I would ask you to leave that kind of language right here!” Oh dear, whatever are we to do with this hostile youth?…

OK, let’s say that Singurătatea florilor is not—as far as the politics of representation go—on a par with the progressive Un film cu o fată fermecătoare (A Film with a Charming Girl), the Radu Cosașu screenplay brought to the screen (by Bratu again) in swinging-sixties Romania, on the trail of a pampered, hard-to-please adolescent girl. (Pancu-Iași’s other feat, mentioned above, set out to speak the language of the kids of its day by inserting go-kart sequences and turning the youngsters into parables of the socialist order.) But in a Ceaușescu-era Romania well on its way to ossifying, there was no way it could have been, short of the haughty pride of a Daneliuc—of which Constantinescu, a drab and impersonal journeyman, had not a trace. More interesting, though, is how the film clumsily mimics a form of modernism: it tries to wring spleen and profundity out of this Bucharest flânerie, even as it advances, ever more firmly, its left-wing thesis: at one point, Beligan lapses—yet again—into his insufferable reveries: “Are carnations to judge us? Are roses to look down on us? No, it cannot be true…” If this is what higher education means, then we understand why the brother runs amok: the last thing he needed was for the scrawny, disagreeable doctor to burst in on him and spoil his birthday with his anti-smoking, anti-drinking moralism… In her review in Cinema magazine, Alice Mănoiu was right to see in this scene—and in others like it, every one of them planted by hand, for instance the confrontation with a brilliant former pupil who has become a factory worker (and is happy with his choice)—“a rather monotonous moral, heavy-handed and heavy-going,” of a “didactic gravity.” The screenplay becomes purely illustrative, an artificial apologia for communist doctrine, saved in extremis by a few great actors. By the end, the protagonist learns a lesson—seemingly metaphysical, in fact purely ideological—about the need to live in community.

Premiera, made the same year, reunites Caragiu and Beligan (alongside Carmen Stănescu, Carmen Galin, Emil Botta, and others) in a “political” satire of the small world of Romanian theater, the work of the avant-gardist-turned-proletcultist Aurel Baranga, who here even allows himself the luxury of a few jokes at the expense of the censors’ imbecility. “Less inspired” than Singurătatea florilor, according to Căliman’s arbitrary judgment, Premiera is nonetheless also less insufferable than the lachrymose Tată de duminică, even if this banks-of-the-Dâmbovița version of the hysterical comedies of the Howard Hawks type—here a door is forever opening, a telephone ringing, an inopportune character barging in—is more embarrassing and inert than amusing (the best gag, which anticipates Caranfil: the actors coming back out for their curtain calls from force of habit, before an ever sparser and thoroughly weary audience). The film carries off its social X-ray with brio, but the conclusion does not go beyond the usual perimeter of action: in the end we witness the consolidation of the bourgeois couple, while the institution of the state theater hobbles off toward a new sumptuous achievement. Overt self-derision ages, as a general rule, better than the objectless melodramatic moods of a Pancu-Iași, hard to bear today—but Baranga’s strategic cleverness is itself suspect of collusion with the regime.

In any case, Constantinescu will not have managed to pull clear of the peloton of an anonymous, perishable socialist cinema. Singurătatea florilor functions today as a curiosity for specialists and “completists”—even as it gives the lie to the nostalgic slogan about the films of yesteryear… And yet one senses, beyond the cramped frame of the car, a real, new Bucharest, at that time in full expansion: had the film embraced to the full its vocation as a drifting, bloodless guided tour, as a travelogue through a capital on the edge of fiction, we would today be speaking of a defining work of this period of Ceaușescu-era zastoi—an embodiment of social withering, of stasis, in the interval between two historical events of the capital-letter kind.

The curatorial texts, reviews and commentary published on en.cinepub.ro express the opinions of their authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the CINEPUB Cultural Association. The presence of a film on the platform is not an endorsement of it, and texts about films may also be critical. Factual errors can be reported to contact@cinepub.ro and we will correct them.

Be more than a spectator!
SUPPORT CINEPUB
MONTHLY DONATION
If you like us, if you read what we write, if you watch the movies we show, reach out to us, friend! We need help. Thank you!
DONATE!
I want to DONATE one time only
2 EURO
5 EURO
10 EURO
20 EURO
50 EURO
Why we need your support?
Be more than a spectator!
SUPPORT CINEPUB
MONTHLY DONATION
If you like us, if you read what we write, if you watch the movies we show, reach out to us, friend! We need help. Thank you!
DONATE!
I want to DONATE one time only
2 EURO
5 EURO
10 EURO
20 EURO
50 EURO
Why we need your support?

You may like this also ...